Wednesday, April 1, 2009

McDaniels/Cutler, the Chris Brown/Rihanna of the NFL

It’s true, the NFL has its own celebrity relationship that has spun out of control. No one quite knows exactly where things broke down, but the way they’ve been spreading rumors about each other The Sports Pad wouldn’t be surprised to hear that a salacious text message from Matt Cassel to Josh McDaniels in the presence of Cutler was what ignited this contentious liaison.

I don’t care if you’re on the side of Cutler or McDaniels, the fact of the matter is McDaniels has failed the Broncos organization. As a rookie head coach the most important factor to a successful team is a clear, defined identity; the one position that helps clearly define that identity is your quarterback. McDaniels has allowed this rift to widen because he continually played the “tough coach” card through the media, instead of silently working it out with his teams best player. Even if he didn’t feel like Cutler was the right QB for his system, McDaniels didn’t need to publicly shop Cutler and engage in this we-said/they-said debate. McDaniels has now become a trivia answer for the question “What NFL coach had the most inauspicious start to his coaching career?”

McDaniels is now backed into a corner, forced to trade the teams biggest asset at below market value. Why below value, you may ask? Because the NFL is an aquarium filled with sharks and when one of them gets bloodied the others circle around for a feeding frenzy. McDaniels and the Broncos have tipped their hand and everyone knows what they’re playing with.

If you’re Cutler you sit back and let your agent, Bus Cook, field the right offers. What do I mean the by the “right” offers? A strong offer from a team where Cutler can step right in, be a quality clubhouse guy and win. This debacle has tarnished his image, painted him as a prima donna and as a guy who can’t win.

If your Broncos GM Brian Xanders, you’ve been getting offers like Ari Gold was getting after Vince filmed Medellin, so you need to drum up a bidding war, which will be tough because you’ll get no help from Cutler or Cook. Xanders needs to find a team with an available QB, capable of starting (which isn’t in great supply) and a player to balance out the deal. Or a team with a draft pick, that puts them in position to get USC QB Mark Sanchez and another quality starter. Sanchez is a better fit, than Matt Stafford, especially for what McDaniels wants to do offensively. Sanchez is better at reading defenses, has better mobility in the pocket and slightly better accuracy. He doesn’t have the laser rocket arm like Stafford or as much experience.

So where does Cutler go? Let’s break it down...

Detroit Lions - There has been a lot of talk about Cutler going to the Lions for the #1 pick, but I just don’t see it happening. As much as it pains me and my Lions fan-hood, the #1 pick is toxic, due to the exorbitant salary and high risk and I can’t see McDaniels stepping away from the “Patriot way” and spending like that.

Cleveland Browns - They have the player (Quinn) and the picks (3 in the top 50) to get this deal done. However, Cutler may not want anything to do with the Browns and the Broncos certainly don’t want to deal him to another AFC team.

Chicago Bears - Kyle Orton and Tommy Harris or the 18th pick almost makes too much sense, that it is destined not to happen.

New York Jets - A team who doesn’t have the QB or the picks to entice the Broncos, but they have been desperately trying to get Cutler since the fallout. They would need a third team in order to make some package work.

Tennessee Titans - The only thing they have going for them is that Cutler is a fan of the Nashville area. They lack the tools to get this deal done, but it would be an ideal fit for Cutler.

Here are the teams I most like the most to sneak into Cutler Sweepstakes:

Carolina Panthers - They have a player that wants to play in a 3-4, in Julius Peppers and he’s a big enough name that the Denver fans won’t feel like they got cheated. Plus, Peppers addresses an area (DE) that the Broncos are desperate to fill. However they don’t have the draft picks (Zero 1st round picks) or the QB (Delhomme) to get the deal done. They will need to include a third team to get Cutler.

Washington Redskins - They have a QB in Campbell and the pick at thirteen to get this deal done. Daniel Synder has never shied away from making waves in the NFL or his organization. Cutler is an upgrade at the position that would be a step toward winning the NFC East.

Wherever Cutler ends up, it’ll be exciting to see where he goes and will drastically shift the NFL landscape.

15 comments:

  1. Eric Mangini is another strong candidate for "most inauspicious start" as well. At least the whole city and team doesn't hate McDaniels...Yet. As a fan of the NFL in general, it would be sad to see Cutler leave the Broncos for a couple reasons.

    A.) No more South Park References
    B.) More importantly, this kick ass rivlary with Phillip Rivers would inevitably get watered down.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Cutler and '09 3rd for Orton, '09, '10 1sts.

    I thought it made too much sense happen... I stand corrected.

    Who got the better end of the deal? Broncos? Bears?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh those poor, poor Vikings and Lions fans. You were all so close!

    ReplyDelete
  4. good deal for the broncs.
    all i know is....chicago is gonna freakn love jay cutler

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bears got the better end of the deal, if you ask me. Just ask the Texans, 49ers, Lions, and Chargers (all of who drafted a major bust in the first round). You can easily spend a first rounder on an unknown "franchise" guy. If he doesn't work out, you are looking at spending another first rounder down the line. It's the safe bet just to spend two firsts at one time, get a young, proven player, and be done with it.

    They also get Orton out of the clubhouse, so there's never any looming "he was doing alright before they went out and got cutler!" nonsense.

    ReplyDelete
  6. great comment about cutler vs rivers feud croce.
    for some reason i always liked cutler in that catfight. rivers was always more of a weiner.
    but now, i'd say it's a dead push.

    i like the bears. am i supposed to like cutler now?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Now the deal looks like: Cutler, '09 5th for Orton, '09/'10 1sts AND '09 3rd.

    Does that change anybodies mind on the winner of the deal?

    ReplyDelete
  8. And Bears agreed to terms with LT Orlando Pace.

    Big day for the Bears

    ReplyDelete
  9. broncs def got the value for what cutler is.
    but!
    we got a broncs fan at work, and he is pissed.
    goodbye probowl qb.

    his justification is....
    mcdaniels is a system offense coach, and orton is a system qb. so it could work.
    any truth to that?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Damn...didn't see they got Pace. that's a nice stop-gap since they lost Tait.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I think the 3rd rounder next year actually tips the scales a bit in favor of Denver. The person who really got screwed here is the average Bronco fan, who spend the last four years talking himself into liking that pasty pudge-faced moron.

    I'm sorry, I don't care how many yards he threw for, Cutler looks like that guy in your dorm who showed up to college skinny, and now shotguns beers before his 9AM sociology class (that he's skipping).

    ReplyDelete
  12. you do realize that the bears have forte and cutler now.
    that's hot stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I've always thought Jay Cutler was over-rated. Kyle and Stan to Jay: "My dad says you suck but that you might have some potential."

    For someone to just step into the Bears organization and be the man at QB...After the rotating door of QB's they had in the past... It's been like a cloud over their team for years. The Bears have always won in SPITE of their Quarterback. Sure, McMahon was alright, but he had the '85 defense on his back. I just don't see Cutler waltzing in there and being the savior.

    I think Pace could very likely get injured again, and if Cutler doesn't live up to expectations, they might not even make the playoffs. I guess we'll see.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Whatever Croc he's going to own as the Bears QB. I've had the non-fortune to watch him in the AFC west for years and he's really really good, grew up a Bears fan and is instantly Abe Froman, Sausage King of Chicago.

    ReplyDelete